| Orange Cards / Sin Bin 22:38 - Jan 20 with 3174 views | BillionR |
I've always thought this was a good idea. Two yellows is an orange and a sin bin for say 10 mins. A 3rd is a red. Some offences such as denying a goal scoring opportunity or serious foul play would be an orange rather than red. A straight red would only be for striking an opponent, spitting etc.
Also only the captain being able to talk to the ref would stop a lot of moaning.
http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/25811977
Thoughts? |  | | |  |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 13:31 - Jan 21 with 3072 views | boobishabang |
Having played a lot of Hockey (yes that sport for birds with skirts) i would say the card system there is a decent one, the Ref can give a player a green card for niggly persistent infringements a player would normally see up to 2 of these before being followed by a Yellow card which is sin-binned for a time at the umpires discretion, no less than 6 minutes but usually around 10, followed by a Red for the obvious which is straight off the pitch, and in my case a 60 day ban  |  | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 13:41 - Jan 21 with 3051 views | daveB |
It all sounds far too sensible to actually happen |  | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 14:24 - Jan 21 with 3003 views | Stanisgod |
Imagine Michael Oliver running around with 4 different colour cards in his pocket  |  |
| It's being so happy that keeps me going. |
| |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 15:38 - Jan 21 with 2954 views | hoops_legend |
No need for more cards... Just introduce a sin bin
I hate the way football n ow accepts fouls as part of the game? Take the Faurlin incident where Warnock was annoyed he didn't purposely foul the guy to stop them breaking away from a corner... That makes no sense.
For fouls like those that he 'should have done' there should be a sin bin rule of 10 mins as there is no intention of playing the ball and ruins football... I as a paying fan want to see actual football not the whistle blown every 30 seconds...
Introduce sin bin and instantly you will get rid of these tactical fouls and also swearing at the ref and linos... |  |
| |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 16:18 - Jan 21 with 2933 views | Antti_Heinola |
oh god not bloody sin bins. |  |
| |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 16:42 - Jan 21 with 2923 views | PinnerPaul |
Teams would just waste time when they have players in the sin bin.
Enough arguments now about yellow/red cards, introduce even more colours = even more arguments.
No need to introduce new "rules" for dissent /OFFINABUS, just enforce those already there.
Won't happen because no one wants to see 9 playing 8 or whatever, and that includes the PL and TV companies. |  | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 23:56 - Jan 21 with 2855 views | smegma |
Still wouldn't have stopped Chelsea getting 2 reds and untold yellows though. | | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 02:46 - Jan 22 with 2825 views | RangersAreBack |
Didn't we have this discussion recently re. Platini? Latest idea is to introduce challenges, 1 per half. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 10:09 - Jan 22 with 2786 views | PinnerPaul |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 02:46 - Jan 22 by RangersAreBack |
Didn't we have this discussion recently re. Platini? Latest idea is to introduce challenges, 1 per half. |
Challenges, for what exactly?!
Just one example of amy I could come up with, why this won't work
AR raises flag for offside as attacker is running towards goal, with team mates and oppo in hot pursuit.
Ref blows whistle, everyone stops, attacker calls for a review, which decides AR was wrong......now what?!
Do we get attacker of team mate to play the pass again and say "Come on children everyone back to where they were when that nasty old lino put up his flag"
Calls for more "technology" not thought through IMHO | | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 10:26 - Jan 22 with 2777 views | isawqpratwcity |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 10:09 - Jan 22 by PinnerPaul |
Challenges, for what exactly?!
Just one example of amy I could come up with, why this won't work
AR raises flag for offside as attacker is running towards goal, with team mates and oppo in hot pursuit.
Ref blows whistle, everyone stops, attacker calls for a review, which decides AR was wrong......now what?!
Do we get attacker of team mate to play the pass again and say "Come on children everyone back to where they were when that nasty old lino put up his flag"
Calls for more "technology" not thought through IMHO |
Fair comment, but doesn't obviate the need for reviews.
A limited number of reviews permitted would mean that an offside decision not leading to a goal would be unlikely to be questioned.
I'd much rather see a game depending on fair decisions than any other 'free flow', or 'necessary Sunday League-style adjudication' pretexts. |  |
| |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 10:39 - Jan 22 with 2771 views | makaveli1882 |
Some offences such as denying a goal scoring opportunity or serious foul play would be an orange rather than red.
No that's a Red as the player is clearly cheating | | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 13:27 - Jan 22 with 2743 views | PinnerPaul |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 10:26 - Jan 22 by isawqpratwcity |
Fair comment, but doesn't obviate the need for reviews.
A limited number of reviews permitted would mean that an offside decision not leading to a goal would be unlikely to be questioned.
I'd much rather see a game depending on fair decisions than any other 'free flow', or 'necessary Sunday League-style adjudication' pretexts. |
but in my case it WOULD be likely to lead to a goal, so why not challenged.
Doesn't answer the question what would happen in my scenario - the more you think through all the possibilities, and any new laws would have to cater for ALL possibilities, then you realise it would create far more arguments than now.
As can be seen in cricket, technology doesn't equal 100% correct decisions.
Blimey, everyone was still arguing about the Suarez "dive" recently 3 days after the **** incident! | | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 15:44 - Jan 22 with 2725 views | themodfather |
and we can have double goals during power plays and pens count triple..an away win is worth 5 pts and jumpers for goalposts!
it ain't broke imo, just improve the standards of refs and get the "asst refs/lineo's" more involved.... | | | |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 16:17 - Jan 22 with 2716 views | PinnerPaul |
| Orange Cards / Sin Bin on 15:44 - Jan 22 by themodfather |
and we can have double goals during power plays and pens count triple..an away win is worth 5 pts and jumpers for goalposts!
it ain't broke imo, just improve the standards of refs and get the "asst refs/lineo's" more involved.... |
No errors from refs/ARs is never going to happen, like no errors from players/managers.
Have to strive to improve/maintain standards of course but 100% correct decisions in a game as complex as football is an impossible dream. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.